Teaching students to question is always one of my biggest goals
for each school year. With the increase of technology and with almost every
answer available at our students' fingertips, learning how to ask meaningful
questions is now more critical than ever. Questioning is a reading skill just like predicting and summarizing that students must master as they become proficient readers of complex texts. Read on to find out how I make my
classroom an environment that welcomes and encourages students to question
everything!
Model Your Own Questioning
Stephanie Harvey said it best-"Passion and wonder are
contagious." Your students will benefit greatly when you share
all of the questions you develop and model how to track them. To do this, I keep a spiral bound notebook on my desk and every time I have a question, I
stop, share my question with my students and record my question in the notebook
for students to see. I keep space between each question, so that as I gather
information about each question, I can take notes. Questions may be related to
a lesson, topic we are studying, or even life events! Students love hearing
what I am wondering about and develop important skills as they begin to brainstorm
and share different ways that I can collect information about each question
that I have.
Keep Wonder Books
Once students have seen how you develop questions and keep track of all of your
wonders, allow them the same chance. Provide students with their own wonder
books. I love doing this with my students for many reasons. It allows students
to be in control of their learning, provides many student selected topics that
can be used for future research projects, and gives students a place to
"put away" their thoughts and questions, especially ones that may
become a distraction during the lesson at hand. You can use anything as a
wonder notebook. You can use small notebooks from the dollar store, the back of
a reading notebook, stapled line paper, or create your own with the FREE wonder book
templates at the bottom of this post.
Explicitly Teach Questioning
Asking meaningful questions is a skill that must be explicitly
taught, practiced, and carried out daily. What better way to provide students
with opportunities to question than with each new book that they read? When
teaching questioning with my students I make sure that we don't refer to
responses to questions as answers. I want my students to constantly be researching
the questions that they have, so we respond to our questions with the term
"our thinking" instead of "our answers". It is a great way
to reinforce that wondering, questioning, and learning are ongoing. Additionally,
students benefit greatly from learning about the different types of questions
that can be asked. We stay away from asking questions that are yes, no, or one
word responses, since those do not require much thinking or
researching.
Instead, we focus on asking more meaningful questions that require
readers to infer, collaborate and discuss, or research. Before
expecting students to question on their own, practice together using a class
size t-chart to model questioning and collect students' questions from
high-level picture books*. Two books that I love to use for this modeling whole class activity
are Knots
on a Counting Rope, written by Bill Martin Jr. and John Archambault
and Sam,
Bangs, and Moonshine, written by Evaline Ness. Both
stories require students to infer to truly comprehend the plot. (Warning: you will all cry at the end of these books) Having
students question as they read can be done with both fiction and non-fiction
reading material. I have students keep track of their questions for each book
on a t-chart graphic organizer. When students have finished reading the
material, they go back and record their thinking on the second side of the
t-chart. I love using a t-chart because students can easily make one of their
own! Looking for more
questioning materials, click HERE. This encourages them to question as they
read in other settings besides the classroom, making it a real-life skill.
Using just a blank piece of lined paper, students create a large "T"
and label one side with "Questions" and the other side with "My
Thinking". Hold students accountable by collecting their t-charts to
monitor the types of questions that they are asking as they read. Encourage
students to select their most meaningful questions that go beyond the text and
add them to their wonder books!
Try this easy differentiation tip! Have
students reread and reflect on the questions from their t-chart and select four
of their deepest questions. Collect their deepest questions on a sticky mat
reading organizer and confer with students about why the questions that they
selected are meaningful. This extra step helps students reflect on the types of
questions that they are asking and motivates them to ask good questions the
next time that they read! Grab a FREE student t-chart and
sticky mat reading organizer at the bottom of this post.
Teaching how to ask meaningful questions is a powerful tool that
we can provide to our students. I always strive to create a
classroom filled with questioning, wonder, and curiosity by following these
words of wisdom from Stephanie Harvey: "Celebrate the question
and learning rather than the knowing."
How do you elicit
wonder, curiosity, and questioning in your classroom?
Check out these other
great ideas for inspiring wonder and curiosity with your upper
elementary students!
From Left to Right: